top of page

The Future of Writing and Authorship

Writer: David Camp
David Camp
Oct 11
6 min read

Updated: Nov 8


Image created by AI
Image created by AI

The short version


I used AI to help me finish The Joy Beyond Reach, and I'd rather you hear that from me than find it in the fine print. At the end of the book, I tucked a few paragraphs about it into the Author's Note. This post is the longer conversation I couldn't fit there.

I know where many readers and writers stand on this. Some see AI as a useful tool, some see it as theft dressed up as progress, and plenty sit somewhere uneasy in the middle. I'm not writing to settle that argument. I'm writing so you can see exactly what I did and why, then decide for yourself.


What Claude did, and what it didn't


The tool I used is Claude, made by Anthropic. When I started working with it, the story already existed. The premise, the killer, the investigation, and the major character arcs were in place, and roughly a fourth of the book was already written.

Here is how the work split between us:


Me

Claude

The story

Premise, plot, ending, every major turn

Suggestions on plot mechanics, which I took or tossed

Characters

Created all of them, their histories and arcs

Kept details consistent across chapters

Themes

Chose every one: assumptions, good/bad buys, confirmation bias

None

Drafting

Directed each chapter scene by scene

Wrote first drafts of the chapters after the opening fourth, in my style

Revision

Edited every chapter, some lightly, some heavily

Proofread for grammar, style, and Chicago Manual of Style consistency

Publishing

Every decision

Help with formatting and the publishing checklist

The working rhythm went like this. I'd talk through where the next chapter needed to go, Claude would push back or offer ideas, and I'd decide. Then it drafted the chapter, matching the voice of the chapters I'd already written.


I edited every chapter before moving on to the next. Most of that work was fixing mistakes, adjusting a character's voice, or rewriting a description until it matched what I saw in my head. Some chapters barely changed. Others I took apart.


Why I chose to use it


The honest answer is time. I started this book in 2006, sitting on reserve at a regional airline with hours to kill and a newly married life at home. Then the job got busier, kids came along, and the manuscript sat untouched on a hard drive for almost twenty years.

I still have a full-time job running a flight department, a family, and a dog who has opinions about when personal attention is required (quite often). Writing the rest of this book at my old pace would have taken me another decade, if it ever happened. Claude didn't give me ideas I lacked. It shortened the distance between the ideas in my head and words on a page.


There was also a second reason I didn't expect. Initially, I was just trying to make the best use of the time I had to devote to finishing the book, but working with Claude felt a lot like working with a competent assistant that could wear many of the hats normally provided by a team an author might work with at a big publishing house. Editor, critic, marketing assistant, and more. As a self-published author, this additional help was invaluable.


I also learned a great deal about the craft. Seeing a scene drafted, then figuring out exactly why it wasn't right and fixing it, taught me more about pacing and dialogue than years of good intentions ever did.


The objections I take seriously


I've read the criticism, and much of it is fair. Here are the arguments that gave me the most pause, and where I've landed on each. I'm not claiming to have resolved any of them.


"It was trained on other writers' work without permission." This is the one that bothers me most, because it's partly true of the tool I used. Authors sued Anthropic over pirated books used in building Claude. In July 2026, a federal judge gave final approval to a $1.5 billion settlement, about $3,000 per book, and Anthropic must destroy the pirated files. The court had also ruled that training on legally purchased books can be fair use, and other lawsuits are still working through the courts.


I don't think a settlement makes everything right, but it matters to me that the writers whose books were taken are being paid. As an author, I would have wanted the same.


"AI is taking work away from editors, designers, and artists." I share this worry, and it shaped how I spent my money. I hired a professional editor. My cover was designed by MiblArt's human designers. When I wanted to quote song lyrics, I asked the publisher for a license instead of working around it. I designed the website myself (with some help from wix.com's own AI agent).


In a broader sense, here's my stance on AI taking anyone's job. Looking back through history, and particularly at the beginning of the industrial revolution, technology that replaces humans has always been derided at its introduction, and the initial impact can't be shrugged off. However, over time, it actually frees humans to do more productive (and more enjoyable?) activities. To wit, I probably would not have finished this book without AI, so it allowed me to finally fulfill a goal I've had for two decades.


"It uses enormous amounts of energy." It does, and I won't pretend my one novel is exempt from that math. It's a real cost, and one I weighed against the alternative of the book never being finished at all.


This video is one of the most informative I've seen about AI data centers. I highly encourage you to watch it.



"If AI drafted it, it isn't really your book." I understand the instinct. My answer is that the ideas, the characters, the themes, and every final word are mine. A draft is where the work starts, not where it ends, no matter who or what produces it.


I saw an interesting opinion on this recently. You can be a writer, or you can be an author. Historically, we used these words interchangably. However, successful authors have been using ghost writers since long before AI came on the scene. Now the ghost writers are using AI. Most of us have probably consumed one of these books already without even knowing it. So, there are still purists who will write (type) every word in a book. They are the writer and the author. There are those like me who use AI to write (type) the words that translate an idea into a functioning sentence, paragraph, chapter, and book but who then go back and edit every word. I realize that calling myself a writer may be a bit misleading, but I'm unquestionably still the author. And there are now services where you can pay $100, describe an idea you had about a book, and in an hour, the service's AI agent will present you with a complete manuscript. The lines are indeed blurring.


Where I drew my lines


I set a few rules for myself early and kept them:

  • The story stays mine. Claude could suggest a plot turn, but nothing went into the book unless I decided it belonged there.

  • Nothing goes out unread. Every chapter was edited by me before I moved on, and the whole manuscript was revised again before anyone else saw it.

  • People get the final say. Two rounds of beta readers read the book and shaped it. One of them pointed out that I was underusing the Beowulf parallel, and that note led to some of my favorite changes in the book.

  • Professionals get paid. A human editor, human cover designers, and a licensing request for the lyrics I quote.

  • Readers get told. That's why the Author's Note says it plainly, and why this post exists.


Those rules won't satisfy everyone, and I don't expect them to. They're simply the lines I could live with.


Judge the book, then judge me


In the year since I picked this manuscript up again, I watched, in real time, the amazing advances made by AI in many aspects of our lives. There is no question that it unleashes people's creativity, even when you can tell that their creation was made by AI. But that gap is quickly closing.


I don't know how this debate will look in five or ten years. Maybe using AI to help write a novel will seem as ordinary as using a word processor. Maybe it will look like a mistake. Either way, I'd rather be honest now than defensive later.


What I'm asking is simple. Read the book first. If it makes you stop and question an assumption, the way I hoped it would, then it did its job, however the words reached the page.


And if you have thoughts on any of this, I'd genuinely like to hear them. Leave a comment below or reach out through the site.


In keeping with everything above: I drafted this post with Claude's help, too. The opinions are mine, and so is every edit.


— David


Sources

































 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
An Homage To My Teachers

When I was in college, I took an education class. It was one of those huge classes with nearly 100 students in it, but it was so good that we were willing to attend the class at 6pm in the evening bec

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Stay in the Loop

Subscribe to get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

bottom of page